Effects of instructional set and experimental influence on observer reliability.

A laboratory analogue of naturalistic observation was used to examine the relationship of observer drift to instructional set and experimenter status. 3 instructional sets (no check, random check, and spot check) and 2 levels of experimenter status were studied. Results indicated a highly significant decrease in observer reliability coinciding with the shift from training to data collection This performance decrement was observed in all 3 instructional set conditions. Within the spot-check condition, reliability on spot-check days was found to be significantly greater than mean reliability immediately before and after spot checks. Further results revealed that observers trained by the high-status experimenter performed less reliably than observers trained by the other 2 experimenters. The possible implications of these results for future observational research and suggestions for minimizing observer drift are discussed.

Deja una respuesta

Tu dirección de correo electrónico no será publicada. Los campos obligatorios están marcados con *